See Hilz, Der Reichspalast zu Ingelheim (Ober-Ingelheim, 1868); and Clemen, "Der Karolingische Kaiserpalast zu Ingelheim," in Westdeutsche Zeitschrift, Band ix.
131) and Clemen (Paulus, i.
See also P. Clemen, Die Portrdtdarstellung Karls des Grossen (Aix-laChapelle, 1896).
4 Bacon (Story of St Paul, p. 198) and Clemen both assign part of the epistle to the Caesarean imprisonment, the former disentangling iv.
Clemen dates iii.
Boise, ' Clemen (Paulus i.
111-152; 1868); Charles, The Assumption of Moses (translation, with notes and introduction, 1897); Clemen, in Kautzsch's Apocr.
412 ff., 655 ff.; C. Clemen, Die Apostelgesch.
De Wette, Mangold, Reuss, Bruckner, Pfleiderer, von Soden,McGiffert, S.Davidson, Bourquin, Clemen and Jalicher) conclude that the pastorals were written in this order (2 Tim., Titus, i Tim.).
The hypothesis has won very wide acceptance, but several editors and critics (including Harnack, Zahn and Clemen) remain unconvinced.